"LIAR" You scream as you proceed to go on about how your Pitbull, it's name is probably something dumb like shnookums, is actually the most well behaved dog you know and couldn't hurt a fly! You are then throughly laughed at by Kitty.
Have I upset the dog lovers, because I don't think pitbulls are misjudged angels? Well good! Because I used to think that. but then I thought about it more. For you see, Pitbulls were literally bred to be aggressive animals that hunt other animals. Animals bigger than itself. "S-so! That doesn't mean they are all inherently evil! They just weren't trained good!" Maybe so, but I seriously don't think you should have to train your pet specifically so it doesn't maul a toddler. I mean seriously how often do you hear of typical dog breeds, such as like a lab, german shepherd or boxer mauling a toddler? Well according to Dogsbite.org on a page listing dog attacks on children from 2010 to 2017 Had listings of two German Shepherds, No Listings of Labradors, Or Boxers. But, of all 67 (give or take they aren't numbered) Listed attacks 50 of them were Pit bulls, not including the ones without the dogs breed in the titles. Those are where I either found no listed breed, a couple Huskies, The two German Shepherds, A Mastiff Mix, A shepherd mix, A rottweiler, a wolf dog and you guessed it PITBULLS. Of those attacks with the breed in the title 9 were Rottweilers. Dogsbite.org also says that for the 12 year period from 2005 to 2016 there were 392 Americans killed by dogs. 254 were Pitbulls. That's 65% of attacks being perpetrated by PITBULLS.
Still don't believe me? WELL FOLLOW ME YOU NAIVE FOOLS TO THE LAND OF ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE. Yes you can say "well this evidence is just your own account so it doesn't count" And thats fine. The above mentioned information however, does count. But anyways onto the stories I guess.
So I have two friends with Pit Bulls and Pit Bull mixes. For the sake of convenience one will be called Ginger Friend and the other Goat Friend. So over the course of my friendship with Ginger Friend her family has had many many pitbulls. And for the most part they were just lovable doofuses who weren't really aggressive. They did still drive me to never go into her house again, mostly because one liked to get up in my personal space. A lot. Anyways though, How many Pitts did she have? Well excluding the many many litters of pups Coco had, she had about 4 by the end of it all. 2 males, 2 females. All was fine and dandy. Until one day Coco went into heat. Nothing still really happened, she got preggers and then it got out of control. The 2 males began to fight a lot. To the point they had to get rid of one because it seriously wounded the other. Then all is fine, their dog keeps having puppies because they won't get her fixed but whatever I guess. Then they get a new dog. Who is not a Pitt. They're told he is a Tea Cup Chihuahua. He is not. they name him Monster. Things are still relatively fine. Until one day Monster is Outside and their remaining Pitt escapes. They proceed to fight. So they are forced to get rid of the remaining Male Pittbull. Now allow me to follow up this story with saying that for the most part her dogs never had a violent history, as far as I know they never bit anyone. So I'm not really sure why they suddenly became violent. I never heard anything while the female was actually IN heat of the dogs fighting. Only afterwards.
Our next story is actually something really recent. So Goat Friend has 4 dogs. Two Pitts, a Guardian Dog and an old German Shepherd. Just like with Ginger friend Goat friends pitts are basically lovable doofuses who want attention. All her dogs got along great. They never fought unless it was play fighting. Until after the Guardian dog is no longer in heat. Then the two males apparently began to fight. To the point they aren't allowed near eachother and can only go outside when the other has been put into a separate room. Again I'm not really sure why they suddenly became super aggressive towards eachother. You could say it was because of the dog in heat but in both instances it was after the dog was no longer in heat. And they continued to be aggressive.
My main point in the stories though isn't to try to figure the reasons why the dogs were suddenly super violent to eachother but to make the point that, even when you think "oh my dog is such a lovable little scamp he could never hurt anyone." They can. And possible for no reason. Especially with Pitts considering they are bred for aggression in the first place.
"Well then what should we do about them" I dunno. There's still always gonna be the naive people screaming that "PITTS ARE JUST MISUNDERSTOOD BABIES UWU" no matter how many times Billy or Suzie gets mauled. And I don't agree with mass euthanizations of a dog breed because some people decided to have aggressive dogs near children. "So ur saying its not completely the breeds fault" Yea pretty much. While the breed can be aggressive, all dogs can be aggressive. Pittbulls just more so because of how they were bred. So it's your job as a responsible pet owner to evaluate whether your home is a suitable environment for the dog you plan to get. Have a young kid? No Pittbull for you. Have a neighborhood with lots of young children? No Pittbull for you. Expecting a child? No pittbull for you. Basically it comes down to, both the dogs aggressiveness and people making bad decisions. Maybe if people paied more attention to how the dogs can behave and took that into consideration when getting a dog, maybe you'd hear less of kids being mauled by pittbulls. But until that day arrives I will still tell you it's probably a bad idea to own a Pitt.
I was trying to type in 3 days and my phone had this website saved in suggested so I came on to check everything out.
So you based this off with 1 website and personal experience, alright let me dive into this and see if we can get some cogs turning. As you said and backed up from the website you find this that Pitt bulls have the highest rate of *reported* bites to people. Is it because Pitt bulls were always portrayed as these horrible aggressive dogs that owners of Pitts decide to report them more often than other dogs? Also, you stated toddlers then gave information on people, not focused at toddlers as well as deaths from Pitts, again not exactly geared at toddlers.
Were these deaths on homes or the owner? Or are these stray pits that were neglected, possibly abused, hell maybe even escaped out of a dog ring after a loss? Was it a horrible owner where the Pitt finally snapped and fought back? There's a lot of holes and I'm not convinced.
Now onto your personal experience with them. So they never attacked you or anyone but got aggressive with each other and that means they'll attack children? They're not the only aggressive dog breed out there, nor are they the most aggressive. When your friend got rid of one male Pitt the remaining one became the alpha, so when they introduced another alpha like and aggressive breed, yes chihuahuas are more aggressive then Pitts, the Pitt had to show that he was in charge.
Onto the second experience, I'm not sure, it could be possible that the dogs were just releasing testosterone because they weren't able to while the Guardian dog was in heat.
Anywho, I have 2 Pitts and a one year old brother, the Pitts absolutely love him, they let him lay on him using them as a pillow letting him pat on them and just generally really gentle and sweet. The reason? Well they're relatively young, about 2 or 3, as well as they were trained and taught well, not to be aggressive unless they or I (my family and people they've been around) are in danger or feel threatened.
I'll read this once it's posted and edit it if I missread anything you typed
I do not go against this, but, however, have you considered those pit bulls may possibly be abused/abandoned/wild (Stray, or feral, more like)? I don't know, I haven't done much research, but based off videos that I have watched alone, alot of pit bulls have been mistreated and ran away or taken to the pound if not killed. That's another thing. Some pit bulls are picked up stray or feral, and become made pets. Then they get mistreated again because that person did not take the time and patience to train/retrain that pit bull. Most pit bulls really can be nice, but their owners are just lazier. A sweet German shephard could rip off someone's arm without hesitation, if not trained, and if also neglected. It just feels like a logical statement, that pit bulls are neglected more, because, well, you know, they can be sweet, adorable and loving creatures. But they could also be a snarling, rabid-seeming beast. And who's fault is that? Of course, the owner. I mean no aggression and/or competition stating this, just simply showing what I think, You know? Kind of a...Debate kinda thing.
The nature of a pet depends almost entirely on who's training it and how. Pitbulls have been historically trained as guard dogs or fighting dogs due to their large size, which leads to the myth that they are inherently violent - just like the "locking jaw mechanism", which, despite public opinion, literally doesn't even exist.
Violent owner, violent dog. I've seen dogs from St. Bernards to fucking Chihuahuas snap at me before, the same as a pitbull might. Pitbulls are just more excitable and are easier to 'rile up'.
We own a pitbull as well as a black lab. Miraculously, neither of them are violent, because we raised them both better than that.
I'm going to have to disagree with you here. ANY dog can be vicious killers if they're raised that way. You don't take into consideration that 45% were from other dogs.
I never said any dog couldn't be killers. I know any dog breeds can be extremely aggressive. Also my main focus was Pittbulls tbh, since there are so many people who just blindly say that "They are just misunderstood" while yea some are, there are plenty of Pitts who infact do attack. I'm not trying to say that "oh Pittbulls are the worst dogs" I'm just trying to make a point. Everyone wants to act like the dogs need to be shown in a better light and not judged as harshly or whatever, when really owners need to realize that yea, there dog is a potentially dangerous animal that can harm them or their kids and shouldn't be left alone unsupervised with them.
Some more quick Anecdotal evidence, not referring Pitts. Once I had a Chihuahua, she was a mean little thing and growled and went after anyone who came to our house who werent us. It was to the point she had to be held so that she didn't try to bite the people. No one really thought to do anything about her though because "oh she's just a small dog she can't hurt anyone" She had snapped at me multiple times and actually bitten me once, continually went after some of my friends and even bit one of them and once we had family over and the dog went after a baby. Still no one wanted to do anything. We couldn't either she was my grandmas dog even though at that point she probably should have had something done considering she was an extremely aggressive little dog. She doesnt live with us now that my grandma moved out, but I am very aware other dog breeds can be vicious.
Also a lot of people like to blame anyone but the dogs for what happens, and sometimes yea it is someone elses fault the dog has attacked because they provoked it. Or the dog is just extremely aggressive. My grandma often blamed my friends for the dog being aggressive towards them claiming they "obviously did something to her" when she had no evidence and it was obvious that no, the Chihuahua was just an aggressive little monster.
Have you looked into statistics for pitbull attacks from males both neutered and not neutered? I have not but am curious after reading your anecdotes with both owners preferring to not neuter the dogs.